This production had dual casts in principal roles. In the interest of fairness to all, we reviewed both casts. Alan Shepley reviewed Starfish Cast and Ben Proeve reviewed Jellyfish Cast.
Starfish Cast
This October’s offering from Adelaide Youth Theatre is “The SpongeBob Musical” from Nickelodeon. As per usual AYT fields a cast generous in size and allows for a twin set of principal characters to participate. I saw the “Starfish” cast. Production team principals Emma Riggs and Kereanne Sarti have sought the services of a youthful production team to bring their chosen piece to life on stage. Director Riley Mobbs together with his MD Alyssa Faranda occupy the key control positions and their combined ideas and effort have succeeded well. Mobbs also designed the (mostly) back projected images as well as chipping in with the program design. A busy fellow indeed.
The company moves across the stage as one throughout with deceptively simple and engaging routines effectively constructed and rehearsed by Choreographer Bailey Wilkinson and her assistant Portia Gardiner. In concert with this movement costuming is colourfully splendid and was coordinated by Kylie Mobbs leading a Wardrobe team of nine! One of AYT’s strengths, as it is in all youth companies, is the impressive number of people who contribute behind the scenes during the period of preparation and rehearsal. Due to their combined efforts this production shines brightly.
So to the characters in this, the “Starfish” cast. Mr Krabs, head of the Krusty Krab food empire is well played by Melanie Filmer, firm of voice and displaying a no nonsense stage persona in a commanding fashion. Krab’s daughter Pearl is also smartly realised by Annamarie De Costanzo, a perfect foil to her father. Together they match strong vocal abilities in the number “Daddy Knows Best”. The two Planktons, competitors to the Krabs dynasty also present as a striking and well timed duo. Eliza Jackson as Karen Plankton uses her pleasant voice to good effect and is also a worthy foil to the distinctive physicality displayed by Sheldon Plankton. As Sheldon, Ramon Alejo really got the audience excited by his break-dance routines that well suited his spivvy style. Alejo imbues his character with a fine comic touch. Similarly Gemma Moran-Machen injected loads of energy with a modicum of quirkiness into her effective portrayal as Squidward Q Tentacles. Her stage confidence and poise was evident in the song “I’m Not a Loser” (with the company) and very well sold to her audience. Mattae Furnari is the French Narrator with the interesting accent. Bonjour Mattae! Ca va? Patrick Green, as the on the spot and on the ball news reporter, kept us up to speed re the volcano’s state of play. And Amelie Mackie whipped in and out of the township of Bikini Bottom uttering various pronouncements as its Mayor.
As thoughtful science type Sandy Cheeks (Ivy Tunnah) promoted her bubble theory to prevent the “Big Bang” from happening. Tunnah provided a great vocal contribution to the number “Chop to the Top” along with her pal SpongeBob. They combined very well. Carter Penley impressed as the energetic and effervescent Patrick Star. He demonstrated great timing, poise and confidence in all that he did. This included a contribution together with SpongeBob and Sandy in their song “Hero is my Middle Name”.
Meri Wagland as SpongeBob gave us an extremely well executed , intelligent and nicely controlled performance. Her level of command on stage from beginning to ending was palpable and with that, along with her strident vocal delivery, she ably led the company.
All things technical worked without any obvious hitch and so, whether you were in the control booth or managing things backstage you can feel well pleased with the outcome. With an interesting nautical backdrop and subtle changes in the light down in Bikini Bottom it all provided a feast for the senses.
Jellyfish Cast
The alternate cast for Adelaide Youth Theatre’s production of The Spongebob Musical: Youth Edition quickly wins over the audience with their boundless enthusiasm as they welcome us into Bikini Bottom. Each number is delivered with high energy, loud and clear vocals and tight choreography, with fun characters to boot.
Maisie Lewis as Spongebob perfectly captured the youthful exuberance associated with the famous character, beaming and bouncing throughout the entire show with a contagious energy. She had the necessary confidence for the role and sung with clarity and strength, earning the audience’s affection as she proved she was not just a Simple Sponge!
Joshua Curtis was delightful as Patrick Star, pairing crisp vocals with his wonderfully clueless characterisation, as Patrick finds himself being idolised by an entertaining group of fans. As well as holding his own in solos, Curtis sonically rounded out several group numbers with excellent harmonies.
In this version, Squidward is desperate to prove his musical talent, and Kyle Mobbs captured this eagerness perfectly in his physicality. He maintained the classic nasal vocal quality of Squidward, and though this made the occasional line a little hard to hear, this did not detract from his performance and his ability to consistently find the correct pitch and volume while maintaining the voice was impressive.
Reese Holt brought just the right amount of Southern charm to the role of Sandy Cheeks, and had us feeling sorry for her as she finds herself rejected by the town. Holt found Sandy’s quirkiness and inventiveness and offered a powerful vocal performance, proving she is one to watch.
Oakley Hyland was hilarious as the greedy Mr Krabs, delivering his narrow-mindedness with conviction and displaying impressive vocal control, even through the gravelly voice he was using. He was well paired with Annabelle Coulson as his daughter Pearl, who showed she is a powerhouse not to be overlooked – by both her father and the audience – and gave one of the strongest vocal performances of the show in Daddy Knows Best!
It is hard to dislike a villain like Plankton, played by CJ Parkinson when he is portrayed so energetically and charmingly! He bounded across the stage with enormous confidence and clearly had a whale of a time, which was a joy to watch. He was well-supported by his onstage computer/wife Karen, played by Elena Pico, who was convincing and committed in her robotic physicality and vocal quality. Freida Jerebica and Amelie Mackie were also confident and clear in their respective roles as Perch Perkins and the Mayor.
This young cast, full of rising stars to keep an eye on, will leave you in high spirits with their energetic performance of The Spongebob Musical: Youth Edition.Â

